Posted by: Pete | November 5, 2007

Categorical Imperative and LIES…

Kant’s categorical imperative strengthens our duty not to tell lies because the categorical imperative states that we should “act only such that you could will our maxim into universal law,” which means that we have the duty not to lie because we couldn’t will the act of lying into universal law.  In other words, if we were able to lie because it was a universal law, then all of the truth in the world would break down because you wouldn’t know if the person was lying or telling the truth.  Another problem is that no one would give to others because you wouldn’t believe the other person when asked to do something.  You wouldn’t believe other people because everyone in the world would have the reflex to lie when put in the position were they needed something from someone else.  For example, image yourself in a place were everyone in the world would lie when they needed something.  Now my lawn needs to be cut and because I don’t have any time I ask you to cut it and in return I will pay you fifty dollars. Your answer to this would be no way because you know that I would never pay you the money and I only asked because I have no time.  This example shows how lying is immoral and how we have the duty not to lie because if everyone were to follow the act of lying, then the promises and truth in the world would be no more.


Responses

  1. I agree with you in that promises and truths would be extinct and we wouldn’t know who to trust. Making lying a Universal Law should never be considered moral and if it was, you can guess for sure that the world would be in a lot of trouble.

  2. Good points with truth breaking down. We would not know who is lieing and who is telling the truth. Basically trust will be gone and trust is vitale in our lives

  3. My head was spinning by the time i was done reading that. If you could, focus more on one topic at a time. Maybe in this new world people would have to use more security deposits.


Leave a response

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Categories